*/
By Peter Oldham KC
Reviewed by Sir Jonathan Swift

Hart Publishing (2025), Hardback 208 pages, ISBN 9781509985418
Studying labour law at university made me want to practise law. My first steps as a barrister were cases in the Industrial Tribunal. Although my career started much too late for me to visit the National Industrial Relations Court, even by the late 1980s ‘the NIRC’ remained fresh in practitioners’ minds, and its successor the Employment Appeal Tribunal retained the air of a court which, even if no longer on the industrial relations front line, was still a place where law and politics lived side-by-side, sometimes too closely. And even then, labour law (as it was still called) continued to evolve under the gaze of Sir John Donaldson, then the Master of the Rolls, but between 1971 and 1974 the first and only President of the NIRC.
Peter Oldham’s history of the NIRC is a fascinating read, both for the law and the politics. The Industrial Relations Act 1971 took industrial relations policy firmly by the scruff of the neck, establishing a system for trade union registration backed by court-imposed sanctions for ‘unfair industrial practices’. The NIRC, which that Act created, was a bold experiment – an attempt at corporatism that used a court to regulate collective trade union action, the single most controversial topic of its day. By putting the NIRC front and centre as the proposed ‘cure’ for industrial strife, the Act served, inadvertently, to find (and then exceed) the acceptable limits of using law as an instrument of social policy and economic policy. The experiment was short-lived: the NIRC came into existence on 1 December 1971 but by 31 July 1974 was gone. The period was defined by larger-than-life characters, not only the politicians and the trade union leaders, but also the judges who included Lords Hailsham and Denning. The original sources this book mines bring that period and those characters to life, and make it clear that Sir John Donaldson was more than a match for any of them.
The hopes and ambitions of all these men, and the harsh realities that ultimately laid the NIRC low, are revealed in the author’s telling of two epic sagas that came to entangle both the NIRC and its President. The first, in the summer of 1972, involved the litigation in Heatons Transport v TGWU, Churchman v Shop Stewards of the Port of London and Midland Cold Storage v Turner. In all these cases dock workers’ jobs were threatened by the ‘new technology’ of containerisation. In Heatons the NIRC’s attempt to hold unions liable for their shop stewards’ actions was overturned by the Court of Appeal; Churchman found the NIRC caught in the middle of a dispute between union members and a union that refused to comply with the NIRC’s ruling; and in Midland Cold Storage the pigeons released by the Court of Appeal’s judgment in Heatons came home to roost when, unable to hold the union to account, the NIRC imprisoned trade unionists for contempt, making modern martyrs of the ‘Pentonville Five’. Only a speedy ruling by the House of Lords restoring the NIRC’s judgment in Heatons provided Donaldson the opportunity to reverse away from the contempt decisions, release the unionists and avert a national strike. The second saga, caused by the Con-Mech litigation in November 1973, was little more than political confection, but signalled that the NIRC would not survive a change of government.
The author is to be commended. His subject is carefully researched and his writing well-paced. Legal history written as political thriller. Not to be missed.

Hart Publishing (2025), Hardback 208 pages, ISBN 9781509985418
Studying labour law at university made me want to practise law. My first steps as a barrister were cases in the Industrial Tribunal. Although my career started much too late for me to visit the National Industrial Relations Court, even by the late 1980s ‘the NIRC’ remained fresh in practitioners’ minds, and its successor the Employment Appeal Tribunal retained the air of a court which, even if no longer on the industrial relations front line, was still a place where law and politics lived side-by-side, sometimes too closely. And even then, labour law (as it was still called) continued to evolve under the gaze of Sir John Donaldson, then the Master of the Rolls, but between 1971 and 1974 the first and only President of the NIRC.
Peter Oldham’s history of the NIRC is a fascinating read, both for the law and the politics. The Industrial Relations Act 1971 took industrial relations policy firmly by the scruff of the neck, establishing a system for trade union registration backed by court-imposed sanctions for ‘unfair industrial practices’. The NIRC, which that Act created, was a bold experiment – an attempt at corporatism that used a court to regulate collective trade union action, the single most controversial topic of its day. By putting the NIRC front and centre as the proposed ‘cure’ for industrial strife, the Act served, inadvertently, to find (and then exceed) the acceptable limits of using law as an instrument of social policy and economic policy. The experiment was short-lived: the NIRC came into existence on 1 December 1971 but by 31 July 1974 was gone. The period was defined by larger-than-life characters, not only the politicians and the trade union leaders, but also the judges who included Lords Hailsham and Denning. The original sources this book mines bring that period and those characters to life, and make it clear that Sir John Donaldson was more than a match for any of them.
The hopes and ambitions of all these men, and the harsh realities that ultimately laid the NIRC low, are revealed in the author’s telling of two epic sagas that came to entangle both the NIRC and its President. The first, in the summer of 1972, involved the litigation in Heatons Transport v TGWU, Churchman v Shop Stewards of the Port of London and Midland Cold Storage v Turner. In all these cases dock workers’ jobs were threatened by the ‘new technology’ of containerisation. In Heatons the NIRC’s attempt to hold unions liable for their shop stewards’ actions was overturned by the Court of Appeal; Churchman found the NIRC caught in the middle of a dispute between union members and a union that refused to comply with the NIRC’s ruling; and in Midland Cold Storage the pigeons released by the Court of Appeal’s judgment in Heatons came home to roost when, unable to hold the union to account, the NIRC imprisoned trade unionists for contempt, making modern martyrs of the ‘Pentonville Five’. Only a speedy ruling by the House of Lords restoring the NIRC’s judgment in Heatons provided Donaldson the opportunity to reverse away from the contempt decisions, release the unionists and avert a national strike. The second saga, caused by the Con-Mech litigation in November 1973, was little more than political confection, but signalled that the NIRC would not survive a change of government.
The author is to be commended. His subject is carefully researched and his writing well-paced. Legal history written as political thriller. Not to be missed.
By Peter Oldham KC
Reviewed by Sir Jonathan Swift
The Chair of the Bar reports back
Conner Wright, Legal Case Manager at AlphaBiolabs, answers the most frequently asked questions about SCRAM Continuous Alcohol Monitoring (SCRAM CAM®) posed by family law professionals
Ryan Prins of Philips SpeechLive explains how barristers can boost drafting efficiency with AI-assisted speech recognition – while keeping full oversight
Finding available counsel shouldn’t be complicated, says Kaan Kartal of Brieflink
By Kem Kemal, CEO, Henry Dannell
By BSK Financial Planning
For barristers, managing anxiety is a professional discipline as much as a personal one, says Annette Henry KC. This article examines the cues, clues and practical techniques for avoiding overwhelm and regaining calm
After a two-year investigation, Karim Khan KC was removed as ICC Chief Prosecutor in July. With the United States threatening to dismantle the court ‘brick by brick’, what’s next for the beleaguered ICC? asks Chris Stephen
Anu Kaura looks at the strengthened employer duty to prevent harassment – in force from October. What does it mean when third parties are in the room?
Kick off your career at the Bar Council’s Pupillage Fair this October – it’s one of the most valuable opportunities for aspiring barristers, says Amelia Clegg
Join us on Saturday 21 November 2026 at Leeds Beckett University and see for yourself why the North continues to be an exceptional place to build a career at the Bar