*/
Two initiatives have been announced by the Lord Chief Justice, in response to a recommendation by the Home Affairs Committee of the House of Commons that there should be specific guidance and training for judges who preside over cases of child sexual exploitation.
First, in all serious sex cases likely to last over 10 days or where, regardless of the length of the trial, one or more of the witnesses is significantly vulnerable, and in all other cases in which a significantly vulnerable witness is to be called in circumstances that call for especially sensitive handing regardless of the nature of the trial or the length of the trial, the case will only be tried by a judge selected on a case-by-case basis by the resident judge and approved by a presiding judge.
Second, resident judges are to be asked to draw up a list of the limited number of judges who are likely to be selected, to be approved by the senior presiding judge. The Judicial College will then provide bespoke training for those on the list. This will focus particularly on how best to conduct trials involving significantly vulnerable witnesses, as well as addressing the difficulties posed by multi-defendant trials in this context. Both steps will be “carefully monitored”.
Lord Judge rejected a further proposal of setting up specialist courts, on the basis that they would lead to greater waiting times and would be expensive to set up and run. However, he said: “It is no secret that I am of the view that more radical options should be considered to reduce – indeed, if possible, entirely to avoid – the need for children to be exposed to the trauma that inevitably accompanies giving evidence in court.”
He warmly welcomed the announcement of pilots which allow for the early recording of the entirety of the evidence of young witnesses under s 28 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999.
Lord Judge’s initiatives were announced a few days before HH Judge Nigel Peters QC gave a suspended sentence to a man who pleaded guilty to one count of sexual activity with a child; the judge stating on the facts that the 13-year-old girl had been predatory and had “egged on” the defendant, replicating language used by the barrister for the prosecution.
The Crown Prosecution Service, which said that the “word predatory in this context should not have been used” and was “not consistent with the work that we have undertaken alongside the judiciary and others in the past year to improve attitudes towards victims of abuse”, confirmed that it would not be instructing the barrister in sexual offence cases while the Director of Public Prosecutions carried out a review.
The Office for Judicial Complaints has received a number of complaints about the remarks and the sentence has been drawn to the attention of the Attorney General’s office as possibly unduly lenient.
First, in all serious sex cases likely to last over 10 days or where, regardless of the length of the trial, one or more of the witnesses is significantly vulnerable, and in all other cases in which a significantly vulnerable witness is to be called in circumstances that call for especially sensitive handing regardless of the nature of the trial or the length of the trial, the case will only be tried by a judge selected on a case-by-case basis by the resident judge and approved by a presiding judge.
Second, resident judges are to be asked to draw up a list of the limited number of judges who are likely to be selected, to be approved by the senior presiding judge. The Judicial College will then provide bespoke training for those on the list. This will focus particularly on how best to conduct trials involving significantly vulnerable witnesses, as well as addressing the difficulties posed by multi-defendant trials in this context. Both steps will be “carefully monitored”.
Lord Judge rejected a further proposal of setting up specialist courts, on the basis that they would lead to greater waiting times and would be expensive to set up and run. However, he said: “It is no secret that I am of the view that more radical options should be considered to reduce – indeed, if possible, entirely to avoid – the need for children to be exposed to the trauma that inevitably accompanies giving evidence in court.”
He warmly welcomed the announcement of pilots which allow for the early recording of the entirety of the evidence of young witnesses under s 28 of the Youth Justice and Criminal Evidence Act 1999.
Lord Judge’s initiatives were announced a few days before HH Judge Nigel Peters QC gave a suspended sentence to a man who pleaded guilty to one count of sexual activity with a child; the judge stating on the facts that the 13-year-old girl had been predatory and had “egged on” the defendant, replicating language used by the barrister for the prosecution.
The Crown Prosecution Service, which said that the “word predatory in this context should not have been used” and was “not consistent with the work that we have undertaken alongside the judiciary and others in the past year to improve attitudes towards victims of abuse”, confirmed that it would not be instructing the barrister in sexual offence cases while the Director of Public Prosecutions carried out a review.
The Office for Judicial Complaints has received a number of complaints about the remarks and the sentence has been drawn to the attention of the Attorney General’s office as possibly unduly lenient.
Two initiatives have been announced by the Lord Chief Justice, in response to a recommendation by the Home Affairs Committee of the House of Commons that there should be specific guidance and training for judges who preside over cases of child sexual exploitation.
The age of criminal responsibility, extreme weather and conflict resolution – plus, new protocol for reporting bullying at the Bar
By David Green
Mário Barroso, Head of R&D and Method Development at AlphaBiolabs, examines the forensic science underpinning hair drug testing, its evidential scope and limitations, and why it remains the gold standard for evidencing patterns of drug use in family proceedings
Unlocking your aged debt to fund your tax in one easy step. By Philip N Bristow
Clement Cowley, Partner at The Penny Group, discusses the upcoming changes to pensions and Inheritance Tax and the potential impact on your financial future
Save the Children UK is the latest charity to benefit from a £500 donation from AlphaBiolabs via the company’s Giving Back initiative
Barrister apprenticeships – shortly to provide the fourth pathway to the Bar – are an ideal opportunity to support local talent and ‘grow your own’, say Tim Coulson and Dr Jane Dennehy
Oliver Lewis spotlights an overlooked yet rapidly evolving area of law – coercive and controlling behaviour within care contexts
Solicitor General Ellie Reeves KC MP discusses her decade as a trade union and employment law barrister, the demands of life as a Law Officer and the number one priority shaping her work. Interview by Anthony Inglese CB
A decade of reviews and research has disrupted accepted thinking in the search for causality. Suicides following abuse have overtaken domestic homicides. Is the law keeping up? Professor Susan Edwards KC (Hon) examines recent cases and the obstacles to successful prosecution
At least not that way, says Richard Paige
