Forget everything you think you know about Cats from the 2019 film. What Drew McOnie has built at Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre bears almost no relation to that particular disaster, the one aficionados have taken to calling simply ‘the F-word’.

Cats is based on TS Eliot’s Old Possum’s Book of Practical Cats, and the premise, such as it is, amounts to this: a tribe of cats gathers under the moon one summer night so that their leader, Old Deuteronomy, can choose one among them to be reborn. That is it. In reality, the plot is an obvious and slightly desperate concoction which exists purely to give each cat a turn at their own song. If you go looking for narrative tension, you’ll be disappointed. But don’t let that put you off. The lack of story has never been an issue with Cats.

McOnie’s great achievement is to have taken a show that could easily feel like forty-five years of accumulated habit and made it feel newly alive, using the setting itself as a collaborator: real trees, real dusk, real sky closing in overhead as Grizabella wanders on to sing the show’s unimpeachable classic, ‘Memory’.

The single biggest decision behind this revival is the return, for the show’s most famous numbers, of the original London melodies. Hearing ‘Mr Mistoffelees’, ‘Mungojerrie and Rumpleteazer’, and the other big set pieces sung to their older melodies rather than the hideous concoctions developed for Broadway and the world tour is like getting a favourite record back on the right turntable speed. If you remember the original Carousel of Progress ‘Now is the time’ song from the 1960s and 70s, and resent ‘It’s a great big beautiful tomorrow’, you’ll know exactly what I mean.

The dancing is the other big change. Usually musical theatre has an ensemble packed with singers who can dance a bit. McOnie has, in a move which really works, cast the ensemble from trained ballet dancers who can sing a bit. Every group number has a physical beauty and precision that Cats, in most of its previous lives, simply hasn’t had.

Rachel Wooding’s Grizabella is the standout performance of the evening. She has one song and one song only, but it happens to be one of the most famous in musical theatre. Her rendition is the best I have heard, better than Elaine Paige, better than Jennifer Hudson, and worlds better than Nicole Scherzinger’s dispiriting outing at the Palladium. The moment Syllabub breaks from the group to help her through the final verse is the moment you’ll realise you haven’t breathed in for the last 30 seconds, unable to take your eyes and ears off the magic on stage.

Elliot Broadfoot’s Bustopher Jones strips away the usual pomposity and plays the character as simply a happy, likeable cat about town. Gary Wilmot brings pathos to Gus the Theatre Cat. And ‘Skimbleshanks’ is a genuine highlight – fast, joyful, and the closest the evening comes to making you want to get up on your seat and cheer.

It’s not perfect. The opening and closing numbers are the weakest of the score, without the earworm quality of the songs in between. And Jaydon Vijn’s Rum Tum Tugger, played here as a slightly lecherous 70s rock star, doesn’t quite come off; his voice isn’t as strong as those around him, and it takes some of the shine off ‘Mr Mistoffelees’, the number he leads.

None of that dents the overall five-star verdict. The audience around me sat in near silence through several numbers, simply watching and remembering their childhood, and rose for a long-standing ovation at the end. We were swimming in nostalgia for two and a half wonderful hours.

At Regent’s Park, this is excellent value: a genuinely fresh production of one of the best-loved scores in musical theatre, in a setting nothing else can match. On tour from October, prices will mostly sit around £40-£70, which is fair for what you get.

This is a show for anyone who loves Andrew Lloyd Webber, anyone who saw Cats as a child, and anyone who wants an evening to share with the people closest to them. It is not for anyone who needs a story to hang on to. Go in expecting spectacle, nostalgia, and a genuinely emotional lift. Book it, and take someone you love.

This is a review of a performance at the Regent’s Park Open Air Theatre. Cats is on national tour between October 2026 and June 2027.