*/
The Bar Council and the Law Society have joined forces to warn access to justice is at risk if the government “ploughs on with its reckless approach” to best value tendering (“BVT”).
The Legal Services Commission (“LSC”) is planning to introduce price-competitive tendering for criminal defence services, and wants criminal law firms to bid against each other for the work. The Bar Council, the Law Society and the Criminal Bar Association (“CBA”) issued a joint statement as they submitted their responses to the LSC consultation paper which proposes a limited BVT scheme to cover lower crime work in police stations and the magistrates’ courts.
In the statement the groups expressed concern that the number of criminal legal firms could be “dramatically reduced”.
They also highlighted the lack of any economic or empirical justification for the proposals. Desmond Browne QC, Bar Chairman, said: “The introduction of BVT in this way takes no account of the negative impact it will have on access to justice. We cannot afford to sacrifice the present robust system for a scheme which lacks all economic justification, and which will have a disproportionate impact on black and minority ethnic practitioners (“BME”). The LSC’s failure to properly to assess the impact on BME practitioners is potentially discriminatory and may be unlawful; it has a statutory duty to avoid discrimination and promote equality of opportunity, and it has comprehensively failed to comply with this requirement. “Solicitors and barristers alike are united in their opposition to a ‘reverse auction’ for legal representation, which is likely to drive down standards, make trials more costly and lead to an ever greater number of appeals.”
The Legal Services Commission (“LSC”) is planning to introduce price-competitive tendering for criminal defence services, and wants criminal law firms to bid against each other for the work. The Bar Council, the Law Society and the Criminal Bar Association (“CBA”) issued a joint statement as they submitted their responses to the LSC consultation paper which proposes a limited BVT scheme to cover lower crime work in police stations and the magistrates’ courts.
In the statement the groups expressed concern that the number of criminal legal firms could be “dramatically reduced”.
They also highlighted the lack of any economic or empirical justification for the proposals. Desmond Browne QC, Bar Chairman, said: “The introduction of BVT in this way takes no account of the negative impact it will have on access to justice. We cannot afford to sacrifice the present robust system for a scheme which lacks all economic justification, and which will have a disproportionate impact on black and minority ethnic practitioners (“BME”). The LSC’s failure to properly to assess the impact on BME practitioners is potentially discriminatory and may be unlawful; it has a statutory duty to avoid discrimination and promote equality of opportunity, and it has comprehensively failed to comply with this requirement. “Solicitors and barristers alike are united in their opposition to a ‘reverse auction’ for legal representation, which is likely to drive down standards, make trials more costly and lead to an ever greater number of appeals.”
The Bar Council and the Law Society have joined forces to warn access to justice is at risk if the government “ploughs on with its reckless approach” to best value tendering (“BVT”).
On both fronts – representing the Bar’s interests and protecting the rule of law
Ashley Hodgkinson looks at drug testing methods and some of the most common ways people try to cheat a drug test
Clerksroom Chambers has recruited Matthew Wildish from 3 Paper Buildings (3PB) to a newly created position of Director of Clerking. Matthew joined the team at Clerksroom on 1 June
... have you seen through yours? asks Julian Morgan
Opportunity for female sopranos/contraltos in secondary education, or who have recently finished secondary education but have not yet begun tertiary education. Eligibility includes children of members of the Bar
Fear of the collection and test process is a common factor among clients, especially among vulnerable adults in complex family law cases. Cansford Laboratories shares some tips to help the testing process run as smoothly as possible
Clerksroom Chambers has recruited Matthew Wildish from 3 Paper Buildings (3PB) to a newly created position of Director of Clerking. Matthew joined the team at Clerksroom on 1 June
In this tale of hope, success really has been the best revenge! A difficult journey teaches Rehana Azib QC invaluable lessons along the way
This article is not designed to offend the Judiciary but the quiet word has only taken us so far it is time concerns were recorded formally, says the first set to introduce an external bullying policy By Eleanor Laws QC, Oliver Mosley and Kyan Pucks
Having represented many Davids against many Goliaths over a 30+year career at the publicly funded Bar, renowned silk Professor Leslie Thomas QC critically assesses what the Human Rights Act currently under challenge has done for coronial law and equality of arms
The Chief Inspector of the CPS knows first-hand the difficulties prosecutors face but is no pushover. He talks to Anthony Inglese CB about Operation Soteria, putting victims and cooperation at the heart of criminal justice reform, and his unique and life-changing career prosecuting the crime of all crimes, genocide