*/
The courageous advocate
David Wurtzel reviews Taken at Midnight by Mark Hayhurst, a Chichester Festival Production at the Theatre Royal Haymarket
Hans Litten stands in the forefront of courageous advocates. In 1931, when he was 28, he led the prosecution of two SA men who had been part of a fatal attack on a group of Communists gathered in the Eden Dance Palace in Berlin. In order to prove the true nature of National Socialism he subpoenaed its leader, Adolf Hitler, and subjected him to three hours of cross-examination (until the judge stopped it), demonstrating the violent, extra-legal nature of his movement and exposing Hitler to a perjury charge. It could have been a turning point in German history. Refusing to leave Germany after Hitler became Chancellor, Litten was picked up four weeks later after the Reichstag fire and held in “protective custody” allegedly so that Nazis could prevent other Nazis from wreaking revenge on him for what he had done in court. Despite the heroic efforts of his mother to get him freed, he was moved from one concentration camp to another, and was subjected to repeated torture. Finally categorised as a Jew (his father, a jurist and holder of the Iron Cross, was a convert) he wound up in Dachau where he hanged himself in 1938. His mother and brother (a theatre director) escaped but chose to return after the war, and died in East Berlin.
The story has recently twice been told in English, in Crossing Hitler by Benjamin Carter Hett in 2008 and dramatised on the BBC in 2011. The new play which transferred to the Theatre Royal Haymarket from Chichester is unlikely to have added anything new. It pruned the story down to a series of tableaux interspersed with direct speech to the audience: Hans Litten in a camp with fellow political prisoners, Irmgard Litten doing her best outside, with one touching scene between mother and son towards the end. Googling Martin Hutson, the actor who plays Litten, one is startled to find a picture of him in Nazi uniform. Indeed he played the mirror image of this role in Collaboration, also at Chichester, in 2009, when he interrogated the composer Richard Strauss. Penelope Wilton, one of our greatest actresses, plays his mother. We largely see her in a series of dialogues (endless cat and mouse games) with a suspiciously unthreatening Gestapo officer who reassures her over ice cream in the park that her son is now in a “model” camp. He shows his true colours in due course. False hope is raised by the arrival of Lord Allen (David Yelland who played the Prince of Wales in Chariots of Fire and has perfected this effortless performance), a Labour peer and pacifist who took up Litten’s cause all the way to Hitler but failed to understand who he was dealing with.
The problem with the play was not in the actors but in the play itself, which came over as both unremarkable and undramatic. The real people may not have appreciated what was really happening but the audience does. Of course Litten would be incarcerated. There were no “model” camps. Hitler never forgave his enemies. Even before the Krystallnacht being in Dachau as a Jew was an end game. History has given this story a tragic inevitability so it is up to the playwright somehow to instil a false hope or even a sense of irony. It doesn’t happen. One is left admiring the indomitable spirit so splendidly portrayed by mother and son (the father drifts through the play but his role in the family and elsewhere is never quite clear). Lawyers will particularly appreciate the scene where Hans enacts a portion of the famous cross-examination. The witness, in voice-over, is played by Roger Allam who illumined the role of Hitler in Speer years ago at the National Theatre. Hutson brilliantly conveys the sense of febrile excitement as he realises that he is getting just what he wants out of the witness, that he is doing this because it is right and regardless of any consequences to himself. It is why people become advocates.
Contributor David Wurtzel
Counsel Editorial Board Member
Hans Litten stands in the forefront of courageous advocates. In 1931, when he was 28, he led the prosecution of two SA men who had been part of a fatal attack on a group of Communists gathered in the Eden Dance Palace in Berlin. In order to prove the true nature of National Socialism he subpoenaed its leader, Adolf Hitler, and subjected him to three hours of cross-examination (until the judge stopped it), demonstrating the violent, extra-legal nature of his movement and exposing Hitler to a perjury charge. It could have been a turning point in German history. Refusing to leave Germany after Hitler became Chancellor, Litten was picked up four weeks later after the Reichstag fire and held in “protective custody” allegedly so that Nazis could prevent other Nazis from wreaking revenge on him for what he had done in court. Despite the heroic efforts of his mother to get him freed, he was moved from one concentration camp to another, and was subjected to repeated torture. Finally categorised as a Jew (his father, a jurist and holder of the Iron Cross, was a convert) he wound up in Dachau where he hanged himself in 1938. His mother and brother (a theatre director) escaped but chose to return after the war, and died in East Berlin.
The story has recently twice been told in English, in Crossing Hitler by Benjamin Carter Hett in 2008 and dramatised on the BBC in 2011. The new play which transferred to the Theatre Royal Haymarket from Chichester is unlikely to have added anything new. It pruned the story down to a series of tableaux interspersed with direct speech to the audience: Hans Litten in a camp with fellow political prisoners, Irmgard Litten doing her best outside, with one touching scene between mother and son towards the end. Googling Martin Hutson, the actor who plays Litten, one is startled to find a picture of him in Nazi uniform. Indeed he played the mirror image of this role in Collaboration, also at Chichester, in 2009, when he interrogated the composer Richard Strauss. Penelope Wilton, one of our greatest actresses, plays his mother. We largely see her in a series of dialogues (endless cat and mouse games) with a suspiciously unthreatening Gestapo officer who reassures her over ice cream in the park that her son is now in a “model” camp. He shows his true colours in due course. False hope is raised by the arrival of Lord Allen (David Yelland who played the Prince of Wales in Chariots of Fire and has perfected this effortless performance), a Labour peer and pacifist who took up Litten’s cause all the way to Hitler but failed to understand who he was dealing with.
The problem with the play was not in the actors but in the play itself, which came over as both unremarkable and undramatic. The real people may not have appreciated what was really happening but the audience does. Of course Litten would be incarcerated. There were no “model” camps. Hitler never forgave his enemies. Even before the Krystallnacht being in Dachau as a Jew was an end game. History has given this story a tragic inevitability so it is up to the playwright somehow to instil a false hope or even a sense of irony. It doesn’t happen. One is left admiring the indomitable spirit so splendidly portrayed by mother and son (the father drifts through the play but his role in the family and elsewhere is never quite clear). Lawyers will particularly appreciate the scene where Hans enacts a portion of the famous cross-examination. The witness, in voice-over, is played by Roger Allam who illumined the role of Hitler in Speer years ago at the National Theatre. Hutson brilliantly conveys the sense of febrile excitement as he realises that he is getting just what he wants out of the witness, that he is doing this because it is right and regardless of any consequences to himself. It is why people become advocates.
Contributor David Wurtzel
Counsel Editorial Board Member
The courageous advocate
David Wurtzel reviews Taken at Midnight by Mark Hayhurst, a Chichester Festival Production at the Theatre Royal Haymarket
Sam Townend KC explains the Bar Council’s efforts towards ensuring a bright future for the profession
Giovanni D’Avola explores the issue of over-citation of unreported cases and the ‘added value’ elements of a law report
Louise Crush explores the key points and opportunities for tax efficiency
Westgate Wealth Management Ltd is a Partner Practice of FTSE 100 company St. James’s Place – one of the top UK Wealth Management firms. We offer a holistic service of distinct quality, integrity, and excellence with the aim to build a professional and valuable relationship with our clients, helping to provide them with security now, prosperity in the future and the highest standard of service in all of our dealings.
Is now the time to review your financial position, having reached a career milestone? asks Louise Crush
If you were to host a dinner party with 10 guests, and you asked them to explain what financial planning is and how it differs to financial advice, you’d receive 10 different answers. The variety of answers highlights the ongoing need to clarify and promote the value of financial planning.
Most of us like to think we would risk our career in order to meet our ethical obligations, so why have so many lawyers failed to hold the line? asks Flora Page
If your current practice environment is bringing you down, seek a new one. However daunting the change, it will be worth it, says Anon Barrister
Creating advocacy opportunities for juniors is now the expectation but not always easy to put into effect. Tom Mitcheson KC distils developing best practice from the Patents Court initiative already bearing fruit
Sam Townend KC explains the Bar Council’s efforts towards ensuring a bright future for the profession
National courts are now running the bulk of the world’s war crimes cases and corporate prosecutions are part of this growing trend, reports Chris Stephen