*/
HHJ Philip Bartle QC reviews a dramatic and confident Bar Choral Society Performance of The Creation at Middle Temple Hall
The magnificent sixth concert of the Bar Choral Society (BCS) on 16 November 2016 was in Middle Temple Hall – the first not performed in Temple Church.
The new venue was ideal for Haydn’s The Creation which depicts the creation of the world according to the Book of Genesis. He was in his mid-60s in 1797 when he wrote what Leonard Bernstein described as ‘one of the supreme music dramatisations of all time’. His inspiration was hearing Handel’s works on a visit to London in 1791. It was written in English and German and was so popular that it was performed many times in Haydn’s lifetime.
The Creation is written for a large chorus and three soloists who in Parts 1 and II sing the three angels Raphael (DeAndre Simmons, bass), Uriel (Andrew Tortise, tenor) and Gabriel (Amy Haworth, soprano) and, in Part III, sing Adam (bass) and Eve (soprano).
The chorus exists in its own right and not simply as an echo or support for the soloists. Its first words are ‘(pp) And the spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters. And God said Let there be Light and there was (ff) Light’, a moment of explosive drama achieved through the chorus going from pianissimo to molto forte precisely on the second ‘Light’ without any pause. This leads to an unforgettable orchestral evocation of that moment. Then at key points, the chorus marks the end of a day of creation and finish the work (with the soloists) singing ‘The Lord is great. His praise shall last for aye. Amen. Amen.’
The orchestra frequently plays alone, particularly the overture which describes the chaos before creation.
It has been a great pleasure to see the BCS tackle major choral works and its thrilling performance in The Creation was without doubt its best to date. I was enormously impressed by the dramatic power and confidence of their singing. Also, the soloists brought great individuality to their singing which rang out in the glorious setting of Middle Temple Hall.
Once again, Greg Morris was conductor and musical director. He was in complete and effortless command of the large forces. The orchestra was the Temple Players. Although at just over 30, they were far less than the 120 at the premiere, the range and colour of their playing was outstanding and fully justified a small orchestra.
This was the last concert by the BCS under the chairmanship of Tim Dutton QC. Tim has achieved more than most in his career and we are all enormously grateful that the BCS is one of his greatest achievements.
Now under the Chairmanship of Stuart Ritchie QC and a talented board of trustees the BCS will sing the Bach St John Passion in Temple Church on 11 April 2017, followed by Walton’s Belshazzar’s Feast with the Parliament Choir and South Bank Sinfonia at the Royal Festival Hall on 17 May 2017. See:
Reviewer HHJ Philip Bartle QC
Philip Bartle has been a Circuit Judge since July 2012 sitting at Luton Crown Court. He was a barrister for 36 years specialising in professional negligence and practised from Littleton Chambers.
The new venue was ideal for Haydn’s The Creation which depicts the creation of the world according to the Book of Genesis. He was in his mid-60s in 1797 when he wrote what Leonard Bernstein described as ‘one of the supreme music dramatisations of all time’. His inspiration was hearing Handel’s works on a visit to London in 1791. It was written in English and German and was so popular that it was performed many times in Haydn’s lifetime.
The Creation is written for a large chorus and three soloists who in Parts 1 and II sing the three angels Raphael (DeAndre Simmons, bass), Uriel (Andrew Tortise, tenor) and Gabriel (Amy Haworth, soprano) and, in Part III, sing Adam (bass) and Eve (soprano).
The chorus exists in its own right and not simply as an echo or support for the soloists. Its first words are ‘(pp) And the spirit of God moved upon the face of the waters. And God said Let there be Light and there was (ff) Light’, a moment of explosive drama achieved through the chorus going from pianissimo to molto forte precisely on the second ‘Light’ without any pause. This leads to an unforgettable orchestral evocation of that moment. Then at key points, the chorus marks the end of a day of creation and finish the work (with the soloists) singing ‘The Lord is great. His praise shall last for aye. Amen. Amen.’
The orchestra frequently plays alone, particularly the overture which describes the chaos before creation.
It has been a great pleasure to see the BCS tackle major choral works and its thrilling performance in The Creation was without doubt its best to date. I was enormously impressed by the dramatic power and confidence of their singing. Also, the soloists brought great individuality to their singing which rang out in the glorious setting of Middle Temple Hall.
Once again, Greg Morris was conductor and musical director. He was in complete and effortless command of the large forces. The orchestra was the Temple Players. Although at just over 30, they were far less than the 120 at the premiere, the range and colour of their playing was outstanding and fully justified a small orchestra.
This was the last concert by the BCS under the chairmanship of Tim Dutton QC. Tim has achieved more than most in his career and we are all enormously grateful that the BCS is one of his greatest achievements.
Now under the Chairmanship of Stuart Ritchie QC and a talented board of trustees the BCS will sing the Bach St John Passion in Temple Church on 11 April 2017, followed by Walton’s Belshazzar’s Feast with the Parliament Choir and South Bank Sinfonia at the Royal Festival Hall on 17 May 2017. See:
Reviewer HHJ Philip Bartle QC
HHJ Philip Bartle QC reviews a dramatic and confident Bar Choral Society Performance of The Creation at Middle Temple Hall
The magnificent sixth concert of the Bar Choral Society (BCS) on 16 November 2016 was in Middle Temple Hall – the first not performed in Temple Church.
The Bar Council continues to call for investment for the justice system and represent the interests of our profession both at home and abroad
By Marie Law, Director of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs
AlphaBiolabs has made a £500 donation to Sean’s Place, a men’s mental health charity based in Sefton, as part of its ongoing Giving Back initiative
Q&A with Tim Lynch of Jordan Lynch Private Finance
By Marie Law, Director of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs
By Louise Crush of Westgate Wealth Management
Little has changed since Burns v Burns . Cohabiting couples deserve better than to be left on the blasted heath with the existing witch’s brew for another four decades, argues Christopher Stirling
Six months of court observation at the Old Bailey: APPEAL’s Dr Nisha Waller and Tehreem Sultan report their findings on prosecution practices under joint enterprise
The Amazonian artist’s first international solo exhibition is wholly relevant to current issues in social and environmental justice, says Stephen Cragg KC
Despite its prevalence, autism spectrum disorder remains poorly understood in the criminal justice system. Does Alex Henry’s joint enterprise conviction expose the need to audit prisons? asks Dr Felicity Gerry KC
It’s been five years since the groundbreaking QC competition in which six Black women barristers, including the 2025 Chair of the Bar, took silk. Yet today, the number of Black KCs remains ‘critically low’. Desirée Artesi talks to Baroness Scotland KC, Allison Munroe KC and Melanie Simpson KC about the critical success factors, barriers and ideas for embedding change
