*/
Nigel Pascoe QC reviews the recent staging of Judgement at Nuremberg at the Bridewell Theatre to which lawyer-actors brought their forensic skills
Judging the Judges is a diverting philosophical exercise. The Bar are at it every day. But in the third Nuremberg trial it happened with a vengeance when four Nazi Judges faced an American panel of three. Was it to be victor’s justice and the least they deserved? Or were there real defences in law which could be deployed?
In recent years, Judgement at Nuremberg has been staged at the Tricycle Theatre as well as other lawyer’s productions, including 12 Angry Men, Inherit The Wind and To Kill a Mockingbird ; all directed very successfully by Sally Knyvette. Any lawyer-actors would love the chance to bring their forensic skills to a professional venue and professionally directed, they can bring authentic attack and real flair to these classic court-room dramas: so again with this new staging at the Bridewell Theatre. The great virtue of this compelling play is that without ever losing its moral core, it is pretty even-handed in examining the issues and particularly who knew what of the Holocaust in legal and civilian circles. It reaches the right conclusion, but in the process, also allows us to follow the fall of a great but flawed German judge. Unlike his co-defendants whom he despises, this Judge has the moral courage to condemn himself. In dramatic terms then, a stonking great speech for a lawyer-actor and a marvellous central part - the fair and modest small-town American Judge.
We were not disappointed.This was a tremendous production, brilliantly directed by Sally Knyvette, taut, clearly spoken and generating real tension and engagement in the issues. The lawyers were living out their dreams along with some professionals, all to support the Paul’s Cancer Support Centre. But this was no amateur production. Pin-sharp casting produced some fantastic performances and a very high level of ensemble playing. As Judge Haywood, Stephen Boyd was totally convincing, a calm and beautifully controlled performance. Crispian Cartwright as Ernst Janning gave the performance of a lifetime: a truly brilliant piece of stagecraft, delivered with immense and chilling control. Peter Hill energetically represented Janning with admirable command and presence. Peter Dodge was a powerful prosecutor, giving no ground.
In the smaller roles, the standards remained impressively high. Iain Christie narrated with total assurance and control as well as being a clearly drawn tight-lipped Nazi defendant. Rachel Lawrence caught splendidly the ambiguity of the German widow. Although her soldier husband had already been hanged, she retained an affection for America and perhaps for Judge Haywood. Peter Cowell was quite superb as a German witness and Caroline Eady skilfully caught the fear of Maria Wallner. Rob McCreath doubled very persuasively, whilst Caroline Havers was a charming and confident local German. Jonathan Taylor an impressive and confident escort. No weaknesses at all in the supporting players. The music, haunting and evocative; high praise to Tim Phillips. Finally a thrilling and disturbing choreography of Khristallnacht by Thea Stanton. Definitely a huge success. Equity applications in the post.
Nigel Pascoe QC, Pump Court Chambers
We were not disappointed.This was a tremendous production, brilliantly directed by Sally Knyvette, taut, clearly spoken and generating real tension and engagement in the issues. The lawyers were living out their dreams along with some professionals, all to support the Paul’s Cancer Support Centre. But this was no amateur production. Pin-sharp casting produced some fantastic performances and a very high level of ensemble playing. As Judge Haywood, Stephen Boyd was totally convincing, a calm and beautifully controlled performance. Crispian Cartwright as Ernst Janning gave the performance of a lifetime: a truly brilliant piece of stagecraft, delivered with immense and chilling control. Peter Hill energetically represented Janning with admirable command and presence. Peter Dodge was a powerful prosecutor, giving no ground.
In the smaller roles, the standards remained impressively high. Iain Christie narrated with total assurance and control as well as being a clearly drawn tight-lipped Nazi defendant. Rachel Lawrence caught splendidly the ambiguity of the German widow. Although her soldier husband had already been hanged, she retained an affection for America and perhaps for Judge Haywood. Peter Cowell was quite superb as a German witness and Caroline Eady skilfully caught the fear of Maria Wallner. Rob McCreath doubled very persuasively, whilst Caroline Havers was a charming and confident local German. Jonathan Taylor an impressive and confident escort. No weaknesses at all in the supporting players. The music, haunting and evocative; high praise to Tim Phillips. Finally a thrilling and disturbing choreography of Khristallnacht by Thea Stanton. Definitely a huge success. Equity applications in the post.
Nigel Pascoe QC, Pump Court Chambers
Nigel Pascoe QC reviews the recent staging of Judgement at Nuremberg at the Bridewell Theatre to which lawyer-actors brought their forensic skills
Judging the Judges is a diverting philosophical exercise. The Bar are at it every day. But in the third Nuremberg trial it happened with a vengeance when four Nazi Judges faced an American panel of three. Was it to be victor’s justice and the least they deserved? Or were there real defences in law which could be deployed?
In recent years, Judgement at Nuremberg has been staged at the Tricycle Theatre as well as other lawyer’s productions, including 12 Angry Men, Inherit The Wind and To Kill a Mockingbird; all directed very successfully by Sally Knyvette. Any lawyer-actors would love the chance to bring their forensic skills to a professional venue and professionally directed, they can bring authentic attack and real flair to these classic court-room dramas: so again with this new staging at the Bridewell Theatre. The great virtue of this compelling play is that without ever losing its moral core, it is pretty even-handed in examining the issues and particularly who knew what of the Holocaust in legal and civilian circles. It reaches the right conclusion, but in the process, also allows us to follow the fall of a great but flawed German judge. Unlike his co-defendants whom he despises, this Judge has the moral courage to condemn himself. In dramatic terms then, a stonking great speech for a lawyer-actor and a marvellous central part - the fair and modest small-town American Judge.
Kirsty Brimelow KC, Chair of the Bar, sets our course for 2026
What meaningful steps can you take in 2026 to advance your legal career? asks Thomas Cowan of St Pauls Chambers
Marie Law, Director of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs, explains why drugs may appear in test results, despite the donor denying use of them
Asks Louise Crush of Westgate Wealth Management
AlphaBiolabs has donated £500 to The Christie Charity through its Giving Back initiative, helping to support cancer care, treatment and research across Greater Manchester, Cheshire and further afield
Q&A with criminal barrister Nick Murphy, who moved to New Park Court Chambers on the North Eastern Circuit in search of a better work-life balance
With pupillage application season under way, Laura Wright reflects on her route to ‘tech barrister’ and offers advice for those aiming at a career at the Bar
Jury-less trial proposals threaten fairness, legitimacy and democracy without ending the backlog, writes Professor Cheryl Thomas KC (Hon), the UK’s leading expert on juries, judges and courts
Human rights cases don’t come bigger than this. Tim Otty KC, lead counsel for the Government of Ukraine in its case before the European Court against Russia, talks about the significance of this landmark ruling and other pro bono highlights from his career at the Bar. Interview by Anthony Inglese CB
Are you ready for the new way to do tax returns? David Southern KC explains the biggest change since HMRC launched self-assessment more than 30 years ago... and its impact on the Bar
Marking one year since a Bar disciplinary tribunal dismissed all charges against her, Dr Charlotte Proudman discusses the experience, her formative years and next steps. Interview by Anthony Inglese CB
