*/
The Children Act (12A)
Release date: 24 August 2018
Director: Richard Eyre
Screenwriter: Ian McEwan
Based on the novel by: Ian McEwan
We know where we are. Outside the Royal Courts of Justice there is a media scrum and the usual rentacrowd. Inside, a calm and authoritative judge of the Family Division announces her decision which means that one conjoined twin will die. Afterwards Mrs Justice Fiona Maye (Emma Thompson) leaves by a private door and walks, unnoticed, to her large Gray’s Inn flat. Here she can sit at her beloved piano, preparing for a Benchers’ Christmas party recital which will pair her with counsel who regularly appears before her. But her classicist husband, played by a charming and virile Stanley Tucci, interrupts with an announcement. Tired of 11 months of celibacy in his marriage to a workaholic, he wants to have an affair.
Except that morally we do not know where we are.
Ian McEwan has adapted his own novel for the screen. The ‘story’ is actually about another fraught case: should the judge allow a hospital to administer blood transfusions to save a 17-year-old leukaemia victim against the wishes of his parents, who are Jehovah’s Witnesses? McEwan has been quoted as explaining that this is based on a real case related to him by his friend, Sir Alan Ward, who is also legal consultant on the film. Sir Alan went to the boy’s bedside to test his resolve to die. After giving the hospital the order it sought he took the boy to a football game. Later he discovered that the boy’s illness returned but, now an adult, was permitted to refuse treatment and died.
"Anguished expressions are thick on the ground here, but McEwan endows the judge with a refusal to say anything. When stressed she can be difficult with her marvellous clerk but never apologises. She will not reply when her husband begs to discuss their marriage"
Things are much more complex here. The boy, Adam, is played by Fionn Whitehead, as handsome as he was in Dunkirk, highly articulate and even more highly strung. And talented – he plays a song on a guitar which the judge knows and they sing together. Who wouldn’t want to keep him alive? But what happens afterwards is not normal. Based on the one encounter, Adam becomes obsessed, indeed in love with the judge. Once restored to health, he relentlessly stalks her, writing poems, leaving messages on her mobile, and tracking her down to judge’s lodgings where he begs to come and live with her. He even manages a parting kiss.
Her reaction is proper. She sends him home. She does not, however, contact anyone who might sit him down and explain the judge’s role to him. For his part, Adam is aware that he is living with parents who were willing for him to die, a profound issue the movie skips over.
Anguished expressions are thick on the ground here, but McEwan endows the judge with a refusal to say anything. When stressed she can be difficult with her marvellous clerk but never apologises. She will not reply when her husband begs to discuss their marriage. He willingly sleeps apart from her for months, awaiting a change of heart, thus curiously shifting our sympathies to the adulterer. Does she somehow yearn for the boy as either the child she never had or the partner she’s rejected? Is this all a comment on the distressing workload which family judges take on? Who knows? When Adam gets sick and refuses treatment we have no idea why and he is too far gone by the time the judge melodramatically rushes to his bedside. At his burial she says, ‘I was cruel to him.’ Actually, she wasn’t.
Everything else in the movie rings true – the behaviour of everyone in and out of court and at hospital is wonderfully well done. ●
David Wurtzel practised at the criminal Bar for 27 years and is a door tenant at 18 Red Lion Court. Prior to his retirement, he was a consultant in the CPD department at City Law School and consultant editor of Counsel. David is a member of the Counsel Editorial Board.
We know where we are. Outside the Royal Courts of Justice there is a media scrum and the usual rentacrowd. Inside, a calm and authoritative judge of the Family Division announces her decision which means that one conjoined twin will die. Afterwards Mrs Justice Fiona Maye (Emma Thompson) leaves by a private door and walks, unnoticed, to her large Gray’s Inn flat. Here she can sit at her beloved piano, preparing for a Benchers’ Christmas party recital which will pair her with counsel who regularly appears before her. But her classicist husband, played by a charming and virile Stanley Tucci, interrupts with an announcement. Tired of 11 months of celibacy in his marriage to a workaholic, he wants to have an affair.
Except that morally we do not know where we are.
Ian McEwan has adapted his own novel for the screen. The ‘story’ is actually about another fraught case: should the judge allow a hospital to administer blood transfusions to save a 17-year-old leukaemia victim against the wishes of his parents, who are Jehovah’s Witnesses? McEwan has been quoted as explaining that this is based on a real case related to him by his friend, Sir Alan Ward, who is also legal consultant on the film. Sir Alan went to the boy’s bedside to test his resolve to die. After giving the hospital the order it sought he took the boy to a football game. Later he discovered that the boy’s illness returned but, now an adult, was permitted to refuse treatment and died.
"Anguished expressions are thick on the ground here, but McEwan endows the judge with a refusal to say anything. When stressed she can be difficult with her marvellous clerk but never apologises. She will not reply when her husband begs to discuss their marriage"
Things are much more complex here. The boy, Adam, is played by Fionn Whitehead, as handsome as he was in Dunkirk, highly articulate and even more highly strung. And talented – he plays a song on a guitar which the judge knows and they sing together. Who wouldn’t want to keep him alive? But what happens afterwards is not normal. Based on the one encounter, Adam becomes obsessed, indeed in love with the judge. Once restored to health, he relentlessly stalks her, writing poems, leaving messages on her mobile, and tracking her down to judge’s lodgings where he begs to come and live with her. He even manages a parting kiss.
Her reaction is proper. She sends him home. She does not, however, contact anyone who might sit him down and explain the judge’s role to him. For his part, Adam is aware that he is living with parents who were willing for him to die, a profound issue the movie skips over.
Anguished expressions are thick on the ground here, but McEwan endows the judge with a refusal to say anything. When stressed she can be difficult with her marvellous clerk but never apologises. She will not reply when her husband begs to discuss their marriage. He willingly sleeps apart from her for months, awaiting a change of heart, thus curiously shifting our sympathies to the adulterer. Does she somehow yearn for the boy as either the child she never had or the partner she’s rejected? Is this all a comment on the distressing workload which family judges take on? Who knows? When Adam gets sick and refuses treatment we have no idea why and he is too far gone by the time the judge melodramatically rushes to his bedside. At his burial she says, ‘I was cruel to him.’ Actually, she wasn’t.
Everything else in the movie rings true – the behaviour of everyone in and out of court and at hospital is wonderfully well done. ●
David Wurtzel practised at the criminal Bar for 27 years and is a door tenant at 18 Red Lion Court. Prior to his retirement, he was a consultant in the CPD department at City Law School and consultant editor of Counsel. David is a member of the Counsel Editorial Board.
The Children Act (12A)
Release date: 24 August 2018
Director: Richard Eyre
Screenwriter: Ian McEwan
Based on the novel by: Ian McEwan
Sam Townend KC explains the Bar Council’s efforts towards ensuring a bright future for the profession
Giovanni D’Avola explores the issue of over-citation of unreported cases and the ‘added value’ elements of a law report
Louise Crush explores the key points and opportunities for tax efficiency
Westgate Wealth Management Ltd is a Partner Practice of FTSE 100 company St. James’s Place – one of the top UK Wealth Management firms. We offer a holistic service of distinct quality, integrity, and excellence with the aim to build a professional and valuable relationship with our clients, helping to provide them with security now, prosperity in the future and the highest standard of service in all of our dealings.
Is now the time to review your financial position, having reached a career milestone? asks Louise Crush
If you were to host a dinner party with 10 guests, and you asked them to explain what financial planning is and how it differs to financial advice, you’d receive 10 different answers. The variety of answers highlights the ongoing need to clarify and promote the value of financial planning.
Most of us like to think we would risk our career in order to meet our ethical obligations, so why have so many lawyers failed to hold the line? asks Flora Page
If your current practice environment is bringing you down, seek a new one. However daunting the change, it will be worth it, says Anon Barrister
Creating advocacy opportunities for juniors is now the expectation but not always easy to put into effect. Tom Mitcheson KC distils developing best practice from the Patents Court initiative already bearing fruit
Sam Townend KC explains the Bar Council’s efforts towards ensuring a bright future for the profession
National courts are now running the bulk of the world’s war crimes cases and corporate prosecutions are part of this growing trend, reports Chris Stephen