*/
By Rosemary Jay
Published by Sweet & Maxwell (2020)
ISBN 978-0414070967
Reviewed by Anya Proops QC
There can be few practising lawyers today who are unaware of the importance of the law on data protection. What was once seen as a back-office concern of little relevance to most practitioners, has now revealed itself as legal regime that is red in tooth and claw, certainly when judged from the perspective of those who control or otherwise process personal data. Whether you are grappling with the potentially significant burdens of the subject access regime, trying to work out how your client can lawfully effect mass cross-border data transfers, seeking to manage vast data breach class actions, working out whether some ingenious new AI poses untenable data privacy risks or even just trying to work out what kind of information will amount to ‘personal data’, the laws on data protection can present enormous challenges, but also significant opportunities for practitioners.
How, then, to navigate the legal maze that presents itself in the shape of the current data protection regime, lorded over as it is by the behemoth that is the General Data Protection Regulation? For most practitioners in the know, there is in truth only one answer to that question, which is that one needs to turn to Rosemary Jay’s excellent Data Protection: Law and Practice, the fifth edition of which has just been published.
Running to an impressive 1,630 pages, this is a book which not only addresses detailed issues concerning the operation of this complex and often seemingly impenetrable regime but also importantly seeks to ensure that practitioners see ‘the big picture’, both in terms of the social policy aims that underpin the legislation and in terms of the interplay between the various different EU and domestic laws comprised within that regime. These are important considerations. The complexity and wide-ranging nature of the regime is such that it all to easy to lose sight of what it is actually looking to achieve, which in turn affects the quality of the advice given. Moreover, it is no good seeking to advise on the full range of data protection issues if you don’t have a grasp of the way in which the GDPR interacts with other relevant EU law regimes, such as the E-commerce regime or the privacy and electronic communications (PEC) regime.
Consistent with earlier editions, this book is well-researched, easy to read and highly informative. It covers all the important topics, including those that many who are new to the field may not have appreciated were an issue. As well as providing a detailed overview of the key principles, there are also discrete thematic sections that address some of the key issues confronting clients. Thus, for example, there are sections on: security obligations and breach notifications; overseas transfers; transparency obligations; subject access; freedom of expression; criminal offences; the PEC regime (particularly important when it comes to marketing activities); national security and criminal law enforcement exemptions; complaints, judicial remedies and compensation actions; administrative penalties; the role and powers of the Information Commissioner and international cooperation and the European Data Protection Board. These sections carefully guide readers through the key issues, frankly acknowledging those very many areas where the law remains unclear.
Of course, post-Brexit, the future of data protection, at least in this jurisdiction, remains shrouded in considerable uncertainty, a point reflected upon throughout the book. Indeed, if recent government policy statements are anything to go by, it is realistic to suppose that, at some point in the future, the regime in the UK may undergo a significant sea-change, with the result that we will all need to adjust our thinking. The notion that, in a post-COVID world, the government may seek to recalibrate the domestic data protection regime so as to make it less onerous for business, and more attractive in particular to the tech sector, is not beyond the realms of imagination. However, for now, Ms Jay’s book presents itself as one of the best, if not the best, guides to the current legal terrain.
There can be few practising lawyers today who are unaware of the importance of the law on data protection. What was once seen as a back-office concern of little relevance to most practitioners, has now revealed itself as legal regime that is red in tooth and claw, certainly when judged from the perspective of those who control or otherwise process personal data. Whether you are grappling with the potentially significant burdens of the subject access regime, trying to work out how your client can lawfully effect mass cross-border data transfers, seeking to manage vast data breach class actions, working out whether some ingenious new AI poses untenable data privacy risks or even just trying to work out what kind of information will amount to ‘personal data’, the laws on data protection can present enormous challenges, but also significant opportunities for practitioners.
How, then, to navigate the legal maze that presents itself in the shape of the current data protection regime, lorded over as it is by the behemoth that is the General Data Protection Regulation? For most practitioners in the know, there is in truth only one answer to that question, which is that one needs to turn to Rosemary Jay’s excellent Data Protection: Law and Practice, the fifth edition of which has just been published.
Running to an impressive 1,630 pages, this is a book which not only addresses detailed issues concerning the operation of this complex and often seemingly impenetrable regime but also importantly seeks to ensure that practitioners see ‘the big picture’, both in terms of the social policy aims that underpin the legislation and in terms of the interplay between the various different EU and domestic laws comprised within that regime. These are important considerations. The complexity and wide-ranging nature of the regime is such that it all to easy to lose sight of what it is actually looking to achieve, which in turn affects the quality of the advice given. Moreover, it is no good seeking to advise on the full range of data protection issues if you don’t have a grasp of the way in which the GDPR interacts with other relevant EU law regimes, such as the E-commerce regime or the privacy and electronic communications (PEC) regime.
Consistent with earlier editions, this book is well-researched, easy to read and highly informative. It covers all the important topics, including those that many who are new to the field may not have appreciated were an issue. As well as providing a detailed overview of the key principles, there are also discrete thematic sections that address some of the key issues confronting clients. Thus, for example, there are sections on: security obligations and breach notifications; overseas transfers; transparency obligations; subject access; freedom of expression; criminal offences; the PEC regime (particularly important when it comes to marketing activities); national security and criminal law enforcement exemptions; complaints, judicial remedies and compensation actions; administrative penalties; the role and powers of the Information Commissioner and international cooperation and the European Data Protection Board. These sections carefully guide readers through the key issues, frankly acknowledging those very many areas where the law remains unclear.
Of course, post-Brexit, the future of data protection, at least in this jurisdiction, remains shrouded in considerable uncertainty, a point reflected upon throughout the book. Indeed, if recent government policy statements are anything to go by, it is realistic to suppose that, at some point in the future, the regime in the UK may undergo a significant sea-change, with the result that we will all need to adjust our thinking. The notion that, in a post-COVID world, the government may seek to recalibrate the domestic data protection regime so as to make it less onerous for business, and more attractive in particular to the tech sector, is not beyond the realms of imagination. However, for now, Ms Jay’s book presents itself as one of the best, if not the best, guides to the current legal terrain.
By Rosemary Jay
Published by Sweet & Maxwell (2020)
ISBN 978-0414070967
Reviewed by Anya Proops QC
Chair of the Bar sets out a busy calendar for the rest of the year
Why Virtual Assistants Can Meet the Legal Profession’s Exacting Standards
By Louise Crush of Westgate Wealth Management
Examined by Marie Law, Director of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs
Time is precious for barristers. Every moment spent chasing paperwork, organising diaries, or managing admin is time taken away from what matters most: preparation, advocacy and your clients. That’s where Eden Assistants step in
AlphaBiolabs has announced its latest Giving Back donation to RAY Ceredigion, a grassroots West Wales charity that provides play, learning and community opportunities for families across Ceredigion County
Despite increased awareness, why are AI hallucinations continuing to infiltrate court cases at an alarming rate? Matthew Lee investigates
Many disabled barristers face entrenched obstacles to KC appointment – both procedural and systemic, writes Diego F Soto-Miranda
The proscribing of Palestine Action under the Terrorism Act is an assault on the English language and on civil liberties, argues Paul Harris SC, founder of the Bar Human Rights Committee
For over three decades, the Bar Mock Trial Competition has boosted the skills, knowledge and confidence of tens of thousands of state school students – as sixth-form teacher Conor Duffy and Young Citizens’ Akasa Pradhan report
Suzie Miller’s latest play puts the legal system centre stage once more. Will it galvanise change? asks Rehna Azim