Patent – Infringement. The claimant had applied for declarations of non-infringement regarding the defendant's patent for a cancer treatment drug. The declarations were granted by a judge who found that there was no infringement of the defendant's patent. The Court of Appeal, Civil Division, allowed the defendant's appeal on the ground that the judge had erred in assuming that the claim had extended only to the solid form of the drug and not to the drug when in solution. Consequently, there was indirect infringement of the patent and the declaration of non-infringement would be set aside.