Sim and others v HM Advocate

Criminal evidence and procedure – Judge's charge – Misdirection. High Court of Justiciary: Refusing appeals against conviction and sentence by three appellants who were convicted of murdering a single victim whilst acting in concert and sentenced to life imprisonment, the court rejected contentions that the trial judge had misdirected the jury in relation, inter alia, to concert, self-defence and sufficiency of evidence and held that the punishment parts of 20 years imposed on the appellants, having regard to the violence used, could not be described as excessive.

Category: