Pleading – Striking out. The Queen's Bench Division found that the first three defendants had breached their duties of disclosure, but that it was not appropriate to strike out their defences and costs orders in the claimant's favour would be made. Further, although the claimant's response to the their CPR Pt 18 request did answer the first three defendants' questions to some extent, it was better to strike out that response and order a further one.