*/
Check the factual basis for the appeal or risk criticism and action by the court, the Bar Council’s Ethics Committee has warned.
In a note, Criminal Appeals – Duties to the Court to Make Enquiries, the committee issued guidance to new barristers instructed in criminal appeals who were not trial counsel.
It sets out a checklist and advises barristers to make inquiries of the legal representatives who acted at the trial in order to ensure that the factual basis for each ground of appeal is correct, and to seek other objective independent evidence to substantiate those facts.
This must be done, says the Bar Council document, ‘whether or not the grounds of appeal may make express or implied criticisms of those former legal representatives’.
Committee chairman, Andrew Walker QC, said: ‘In several recent decisions, the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division has clarified and emphasised the importance of some particular duties to the court when fresh counsel are instructed to represent a convicted defendant in a criminal appeal.
‘When the Court of Appeal highlights an issue such as this, you don’t ignore it. Barristers must not get caught out’.
He said: ‘The Court of Appeal is clearly concerned that in some cases, appeals are being advanced on grounds which turn out to be factually wrong, and has indicated that it will take a strict line with those who do not comply with their duties in this respect.
‘In extreme cases, this could even include referral to the regulator,’ he said.
Check the factual basis for the appeal or risk criticism and action by the court, the Bar Council’s Ethics Committee has warned.
In a note, Criminal Appeals – Duties to the Court to Make Enquiries, the committee issued guidance to new barristers instructed in criminal appeals who were not trial counsel.
It sets out a checklist and advises barristers to make inquiries of the legal representatives who acted at the trial in order to ensure that the factual basis for each ground of appeal is correct, and to seek other objective independent evidence to substantiate those facts.
This must be done, says the Bar Council document, ‘whether or not the grounds of appeal may make express or implied criticisms of those former legal representatives’.
Committee chairman, Andrew Walker QC, said: ‘In several recent decisions, the Court of Appeal, Criminal Division has clarified and emphasised the importance of some particular duties to the court when fresh counsel are instructed to represent a convicted defendant in a criminal appeal.
‘When the Court of Appeal highlights an issue such as this, you don’t ignore it. Barristers must not get caught out’.
He said: ‘The Court of Appeal is clearly concerned that in some cases, appeals are being advanced on grounds which turn out to be factually wrong, and has indicated that it will take a strict line with those who do not comply with their duties in this respect.
‘In extreme cases, this could even include referral to the regulator,’ he said.
Now is the time to tackle inappropriate behaviour at the Bar as well as extend our reach and collaboration with organisations and individuals at home and abroad
A comparison – Dan Monaghan, Head of DWF Chambers, invites two viewpoints
And if not, why not? asks Louise Crush of Westgate Wealth Management
Marie Law, Head of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs, discusses the many benefits of oral fluid drug testing for child welfare and protection matters
To mark International Women’s Day, Louise Crush of Westgate Wealth Management looks at how financial planning can help bridge the gap
Casey Randall of AlphaBiolabs answers some of the most common questions regarding relationship DNA testing for court
Maria Scotland and Niamh Wilkie report from the Bar Council’s 2024 visit to the United Arab Emirates exploring practice development opportunities for the England and Wales family Bar
Marking Neurodiversity Week 2025, an anonymous barrister shares the revelations and emotions from a mid-career diagnosis with a view to encouraging others to find out more
David Wurtzel analyses the outcome of the 2024 silk competition and how it compares with previous years, revealing some striking trends and home truths for the profession
Save for some high-flyers and those who can become commercial arbitrators, it is generally a question of all or nothing but that does not mean moving from hero to zero, says Andrew Hillier
