Mr Bennett was granted bail by Justice Tedius Karwe of the Zimbabwean High Court on Tuesday 3 March but that decision was overturned on Wednesday 4 March by Justice Paddington Garwe in the Supreme Court upon the Zimbabwean Attorney General’s appeal. Mr Chipadze’s order of Tuesday 3 March appears to have been in accordance with the High Court order then in force.
The arrest of any judge, save in the most exceptional circumstances, will inevitably raise very serious issues relating to the rule of law. The conduct of Zimbabwean state authorities before the courts has frequently given cause for grave concern. The arrest and detention of Mr Chipadze, apparently because he made a judicial decision that was contrary to the interests of some elements of the Zimbabwean state, is particularly disturbing.
We note reports that other magistrates in Mutare went on strike in support of Mr Chipadze. We have heard unconfirmed reports that Mr Chipadze was released on bail over the weekend but that he still faces criminal proceedings. Whether or not he has been released, his arrest and detention appear to have been serious breaches of the principle of judicial independence.
The signatories to this statement ask the Zimbabwean authorities to abide by the Unity Government’s commitment to the rule of law and immediately to withdraw any criminal charges against Mr Chipadze. Such serious mistreatment of a judicial officer is inconsistent with the rule of law.