*/
A number of rape and sexual assault cases could be dropped, the Director of Public Prosecutions admitted after she announced an urgent review to ensure evidence has been disclosed properly.
Alison Saunders launched the review after the collapse of four rape trials due to the failure by the police or Crown Prosecution Service to disclose digital evidence, which emerged at the last minute and cast doubt on the allegations made. A people-trafficking trial also collapsed due to the failure to disclose crucial evidence.
Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Saunders had previously said the cases showed that the justice system was working and that as far as she could tell, no-one is in jail after being wrongly convicted due to disclosure failures.
The Attorney General, Jeremy Wright QC, said there was no evidence of ‘widespread malpractice or dishonesty’, but said police and prosecutors were not carrying out basic disclosure procedures.
But the former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge, told The Times he feared rapists will get away with their crimes because police and prosecution failings have undermined public confidence in the justice system.
Juries, he said, could be deterred from convicting in sexual assault trials because they would not have faith in evidence placed before the court.
The former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd told the Today programme ‘this is a systemic problem’ that has been flagged up by the Court of Appeal two and half years ago, but not dealt with.
See 'Disclosure in criminal cases: it's not rocket science'.
A number of rape and sexual assault cases could be dropped, the Director of Public Prosecutions admitted after she announced an urgent review to ensure evidence has been disclosed properly.
Alison Saunders launched the review after the collapse of four rape trials due to the failure by the police or Crown Prosecution Service to disclose digital evidence, which emerged at the last minute and cast doubt on the allegations made. A people-trafficking trial also collapsed due to the failure to disclose crucial evidence.
Speaking to BBC Radio 4’s Today programme, Saunders had previously said the cases showed that the justice system was working and that as far as she could tell, no-one is in jail after being wrongly convicted due to disclosure failures.
The Attorney General, Jeremy Wright QC, said there was no evidence of ‘widespread malpractice or dishonesty’, but said police and prosecutors were not carrying out basic disclosure procedures.
But the former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Judge, told The Times he feared rapists will get away with their crimes because police and prosecution failings have undermined public confidence in the justice system.
Juries, he said, could be deterred from convicting in sexual assault trials because they would not have faith in evidence placed before the court.
The former Lord Chief Justice, Lord Thomas of Cwmgiedd told the Today programme ‘this is a systemic problem’ that has been flagged up by the Court of Appeal two and half years ago, but not dealt with.
See 'Disclosure in criminal cases: it's not rocket science'.
As we look ahead to Justice Week 2022, the sustainability of the Criminal Bar remains a critical issue for the government to address
Opportunity for female sopranos/contraltos in secondary education, or who have recently finished secondary education but have not yet begun tertiary education. Eligibility includes children of members of the Bar
Fear of the collection and test process is a common factor among clients, especially among vulnerable adults in complex family law cases. Cansford Laboratories shares some tips to help the testing process run as smoothly as possible
Casey Randall explains how complex relationship DNA tests can best be used – and interpreted – by counsel
Casey Randall, Head of DNA at AlphaBiolabs, explores what barristers need to know about DNA testing for immigration, including when a client might wish to submit DNA evidence, and which relationship tests are best for immigration applications
Julian Morgan reminds barristers of the top five areas to consider before 5 April
The case ofR v Brecanihas complicated matters for defence lawyers. Emma Fielding talks to gang culture expert, Dr Simon Harding about County Lines, exploitation and modern slavery
Barristers are particularly at risk of burnout because of the nature of our work and our approach to it but it doesnt have to be this way. Jade Bucklow explores how culture, work and lifestyle changes can rejuvinate our mental health...
Professionally embarrassed? The circumstances in which criminal barristers may return instructions to appear at trial have become clearer following the Court of Appeal judgment inR v Daniels By Abigail Bright
The Schools Consent Project (SCP) is educating tens of thousands of teenagers about the law around consent to challenge and change what is now endemic behaviour. Here, its founder, barrister Kate Parker talks to Chris Henley QC about SCPs work and its association with Jodie Comers West End playPrima Facie, in which she plays a criminal barrister who is sexually assaulted
Following the launch of the Life at the Young Bar report and a nationwide listening exercise, Michael Polak and Michael Harwood outline the Young Barristers Committees raft of initiatives designed to address your issues of concern