*/
Acourt ruling on legal professional privilege during EU cartel investigations has sparked concern across the legal profession.
In Akzo Nobel Chemicals and Akcros Chemicals v European Commission (Case C-550/07 P), the ECJ ruled that internal communications by in-house lawyers are not protected by legal professional privilege in EU competition law investigations.
Sir Christopher Bellamy QC, senior consultant at Linklaters, said: “This is a disappointing judgment. In modern circumstances the primary enforcer of competition law is often the in-house lawyer. In my view, that role should be strengthened, not weakened.”
Des Hudson, chief executive of the Law Society, said in-house lawyers were “the front-line guarantor of compliance” and companies would only ask difficult or sensitive questions when they knew they could do so in confidence.
European Commission officials seized correspondence between employees and in-house counsel during a 2003 anti-competitive investigations raid on Akzo Nobel’s Manchester offices. The company unsuccessfully argued that the documents were protected by privilege.
Geraldine Elliott, head of commercial litigation at Reynolds Porter Chamberlain LLP, said companies will wonder why European law trumps long-held national legal traditions and creates this kind of anomaly: “The court concluded that as a result of the in-house counsel’s ‘economic dependence’ on his employer he does not enjoy a level of professional independence comparable to that of lawyers in private practice ... In-house counsel at businesses where European competition investigations are a realistic prospect will have to be very careful about writing down anything that could be used against the company in the event of an investigation,” she added.
In Akzo Nobel Chemicals and Akcros Chemicals v European Commission (Case C-550/07 P), the ECJ ruled that internal communications by in-house lawyers are not protected by legal professional privilege in EU competition law investigations.
Sir Christopher Bellamy QC, senior consultant at Linklaters, said: “This is a disappointing judgment. In modern circumstances the primary enforcer of competition law is often the in-house lawyer. In my view, that role should be strengthened, not weakened.”
Des Hudson, chief executive of the Law Society, said in-house lawyers were “the front-line guarantor of compliance” and companies would only ask difficult or sensitive questions when they knew they could do so in confidence.
European Commission officials seized correspondence between employees and in-house counsel during a 2003 anti-competitive investigations raid on Akzo Nobel’s Manchester offices. The company unsuccessfully argued that the documents were protected by privilege.
Geraldine Elliott, head of commercial litigation at Reynolds Porter Chamberlain LLP, said companies will wonder why European law trumps long-held national legal traditions and creates this kind of anomaly: “The court concluded that as a result of the in-house counsel’s ‘economic dependence’ on his employer he does not enjoy a level of professional independence comparable to that of lawyers in private practice ... In-house counsel at businesses where European competition investigations are a realistic prospect will have to be very careful about writing down anything that could be used against the company in the event of an investigation,” she added.
Acourt ruling on legal professional privilege during EU cartel investigations has sparked concern across the legal profession.
On both fronts – representing the Bar’s interests and protecting the rule of law
Kate West discusses how best to interpret a drug test report, and the common misconceptions about what can be learnt from a drug test
Ashley Hodgkinson looks at drug testing methods and some of the most common ways people try to cheat a drug test
Clerksroom Chambers has recruited Matthew Wildish from 3 Paper Buildings (3PB) to a newly created position of Director of Clerking. Matthew joined the team at Clerksroom on 1 June
... have you seen through yours? asks Julian Morgan
Opportunity for female sopranos/contraltos in secondary education, or who have recently finished secondary education but have not yet begun tertiary education. Eligibility includes children of members of the Bar
Clerksroom Chambers has recruited Matthew Wildish from 3 Paper Buildings (3PB) to a newly created position of Director of Clerking. Matthew joined the team at Clerksroom on 1 June
Ashley Hodgkinson looks at drug testing methods and some of the most common ways people try to cheat a drug test
Kate West discusses how best to interpret a drug test report, and the common misconceptions about what can be learnt from a drug test
