*/
Profession
The actor Martin Shaw denounced the prospect of industrial-scale legal practices when delivering the 2012 Kalisher Lecture. An Honorary Bencher of Gray’s Inn and a Kalisher trustee, he described himself as an “informed outsider” who has grown to respect and admire the legal profession “more than I had ever imagined possible”. In addition, he has a daughter beginning the “long and arduous road” into the profession.
Addressing barristers, the senior judiciary, and law students, he was unsparing in his analysis of proposed changes to the structure of the publicly funded Bar. He described a future in which talented candidates from diverse backgrounds no longer aspire to become criminal barristers. They dare not risk the inevitable level of debt in the context of a shrinking profession which will leave even the brightest and best with little prospect of a tenancy.
Mr Shaw set out the challenges: public ignorance and apathy about the fate of the criminal Bar, swingeing cuts to legal aid imposed by two successive Governments, and rising tuition fees - more than £60,000 of debt on entry to the profession is not remarkable. He drew parallels to television drama: when the BBC has to enter a ratings war, it is more likely to produce ‘X Factor’ than Shakespeare. Similarly, a bulk legal service will replace a personal one. “Never mind the lament for the high street butcher, cheesemonger, baker, ironmonger. You’ll struggle to find a high street solicitor before long.”
Articulating his fear that the ‘Bar is in very real danger’, Mr Shaw emphasised the importance of the criminal barrister: an independent specialist whose overriding responsibility is to see justice done. Deregulation would lead to “a no-frills, cheap and cheerful bulk legal service. Tesco Law, Asda Legal, and, for the cachet of a Silk, Waitrose Lex.” His view is that excellence produces justice. Bulk commerce on the other hand trades in adequacy.
Mr Shaw called on the Government to “pull back from proposals which will so erode the Bar as to destroy it.” This is a small profession of highly trained experts, providing the public with a service it deserves and upon which it relies without a moment’s thought.Drawing an analogy with medicine, he said: “When I go into hospital I want someone trained and practising for years. And when I’m having my hip replaced, I don’t want it done by a dentist.”
He considers criminal law stratified, difficult, ever-expanding, hard to master and very hard to keep abreast of. In-house advocacy will not be cheaper and just as good. Things will go wrong, and the Court of Appeal is an expensive place.
Addressing barristers, the senior judiciary, and law students, he was unsparing in his analysis of proposed changes to the structure of the publicly funded Bar. He described a future in which talented candidates from diverse backgrounds no longer aspire to become criminal barristers. They dare not risk the inevitable level of debt in the context of a shrinking profession which will leave even the brightest and best with little prospect of a tenancy.
Mr Shaw set out the challenges: public ignorance and apathy about the fate of the criminal Bar, swingeing cuts to legal aid imposed by two successive Governments, and rising tuition fees - more than £60,000 of debt on entry to the profession is not remarkable. He drew parallels to television drama: when the BBC has to enter a ratings war, it is more likely to produce ‘X Factor’ than Shakespeare. Similarly, a bulk legal service will replace a personal one. “Never mind the lament for the high street butcher, cheesemonger, baker, ironmonger. You’ll struggle to find a high street solicitor before long.”
Articulating his fear that the ‘Bar is in very real danger’, Mr Shaw emphasised the importance of the criminal barrister: an independent specialist whose overriding responsibility is to see justice done. Deregulation would lead to “a no-frills, cheap and cheerful bulk legal service. Tesco Law, Asda Legal, and, for the cachet of a Silk, Waitrose Lex.” His view is that excellence produces justice. Bulk commerce on the other hand trades in adequacy.
Mr Shaw called on the Government to “pull back from proposals which will so erode the Bar as to destroy it.” This is a small profession of highly trained experts, providing the public with a service it deserves and upon which it relies without a moment’s thought.Drawing an analogy with medicine, he said: “When I go into hospital I want someone trained and practising for years. And when I’m having my hip replaced, I don’t want it done by a dentist.”
He considers criminal law stratified, difficult, ever-expanding, hard to master and very hard to keep abreast of. In-house advocacy will not be cheaper and just as good. Things will go wrong, and the Court of Appeal is an expensive place.
Profession
The actor Martin Shaw denounced the prospect of industrial-scale legal practices when delivering the 2012 Kalisher Lecture. An Honorary Bencher of Gray’s Inn and a Kalisher trustee, he described himself as an “informed outsider” who has grown to respect and admire the legal profession “more than I had ever imagined possible”. In addition, he has a daughter beginning the “long and arduous road” into the profession.
The age of criminal responsibility, extreme weather and conflict resolution – plus, new protocol for reporting bullying at the Bar
By David Green
Mário Barroso, Head of R&D and Method Development at AlphaBiolabs, examines the forensic science underpinning hair drug testing, its evidential scope and limitations, and why it remains the gold standard for evidencing patterns of drug use in family proceedings
Unlocking your aged debt to fund your tax in one easy step. By Philip N Bristow
Clement Cowley, Partner at The Penny Group, discusses the upcoming changes to pensions and Inheritance Tax and the potential impact on your financial future
Save the Children UK is the latest charity to benefit from a £500 donation from AlphaBiolabs via the company’s Giving Back initiative
Barrister apprenticeships – shortly to provide the fourth pathway to the Bar – are an ideal opportunity to support local talent and ‘grow your own’, say Tim Coulson and Dr Jane Dennehy
Oliver Lewis spotlights an overlooked yet rapidly evolving area of law – coercive and controlling behaviour within care contexts
Solicitor General Ellie Reeves KC MP discusses her decade as a trade union and employment law barrister, the demands of life as a Law Officer and the number one priority shaping her work. Interview by Anthony Inglese CB
A decade of reviews and research has disrupted accepted thinking in the search for causality. Suicides following abuse have overtaken domestic homicides. Is the law keeping up? Professor Susan Edwards KC (Hon) examines recent cases and the obstacles to successful prosecution
At least not that way, says Richard Paige
