*/
The ‘legislative tsunami’ triggered by Brexit is the ‘greatest challenge’ ever faced by our legislative processes, Lord Judge said.
Delivering the annual Bingham Lecture, Judge, who served as Lord Chief Justice between 2008 and 2013, bemoaned the ‘torrent’ of legislation generally, which he said is not properly scrutinised.
Spending increasing time in the House of Lords, he said, has changed the way he sees the legislative process. ‘The process of scrutiny, which provides the basis for Parliamentary control of the executive has... diminished, is diminishing, and ought to be increased’.
While Bills are getting longer, Judge said many are ‘not much more than intended political propaganda’. ‘Skeleton’ Bills, like the Education and Adoption Bill and Cities and Local Government Devolution Bill, he said, leave much of the detail to secondary legislation. While ‘Christmas Tree’ Bills, which have ‘grand’ and focused titles, are then ‘festooned with multiple miscellaneous’ and potentially controversial provisions that have no apparent connection with their titles, in the hope they will escape scrutiny.
Judge said: ‘During the last few years something like 3,000 typed pages of primary legislation have been produced annually, and in addition laws are made by some 12,000- 13,000 pages of delegated legislation.’
Legislative scrutiny, he said, is an essential ingredient of Parliamentary democracy. ‘The government should be held to account for its actions, and its policies, and consequentially for the laws it seeks to enact to implement its policies and legitimise its actions.’
The ‘legislative tsunami’ triggered by Brexit is the ‘greatest challenge’ ever faced by our legislative processes, Lord Judge said.
Delivering the annual Bingham Lecture, Judge, who served as Lord Chief Justice between 2008 and 2013, bemoaned the ‘torrent’ of legislation generally, which he said is not properly scrutinised.
Spending increasing time in the House of Lords, he said, has changed the way he sees the legislative process. ‘The process of scrutiny, which provides the basis for Parliamentary control of the executive has... diminished, is diminishing, and ought to be increased’.
While Bills are getting longer, Judge said many are ‘not much more than intended political propaganda’. ‘Skeleton’ Bills, like the Education and Adoption Bill and Cities and Local Government Devolution Bill, he said, leave much of the detail to secondary legislation. While ‘Christmas Tree’ Bills, which have ‘grand’ and focused titles, are then ‘festooned with multiple miscellaneous’ and potentially controversial provisions that have no apparent connection with their titles, in the hope they will escape scrutiny.
Judge said: ‘During the last few years something like 3,000 typed pages of primary legislation have been produced annually, and in addition laws are made by some 12,000- 13,000 pages of delegated legislation.’
Legislative scrutiny, he said, is an essential ingredient of Parliamentary democracy. ‘The government should be held to account for its actions, and its policies, and consequentially for the laws it seeks to enact to implement its policies and legitimise its actions.’
Justice system requires urgent attention and next steps on the Harman Review
Q&A with Tim Lynch of Jordan Lynch Private Finance
By Marie Law, Director of Toxicology at AlphaBiolabs
By Louise Crush of Westgate Wealth Management
Why Virtual Assistants Can Meet the Legal Profession’s Exacting Standards
Six months of court observation at the Old Bailey: APPEAL’s Dr Nisha Waller and Tehreem Sultan report their findings on prosecution practices under joint enterprise
The Amazonian artist’s first international solo exhibition is wholly relevant to current issues in social and environmental justice, says Stephen Cragg KC
Despite its prevalence, autism spectrum disorder remains poorly understood in the criminal justice system. Does Alex Henry’s joint enterprise conviction expose the need to audit prisons? asks Dr Felicity Gerry KC
Until reforms are instituted and a programme of training is introduced, expert opinion on intimate partner abuse remains vital to realigning the tilted scales of law and justice, writes Professor Susan Edwards
It’s been five years since the groundbreaking QC competition in which six Black women barristers, including the 2025 Chair of the Bar, took silk. Yet today, the number of Black KCs remains ‘critically low’. Desirée Artesi talks to Baroness Scotland KC, Allison Munroe KC and Melanie Simpson KC about the critical success factors, barriers and ideas for embedding change
