*/
Lord Steyn, a former Lord of Appeal in Ordinary, has called for the identity card scheme to be abandoned.
Speaking at the Farrer’s Building second biennial lecture in memory of Lord Williams of Mostyn, Lord Steyn highlighted the lack of evidence that a National Identity Register – which will store geographical information, biometric data and administrative data linked to the use of ID cards – will serve to combat serious crime, and expressed concerns about the privacy implications for members of the public given the series of security leaks which have occurred.
“In my view a national identity card system is not necessary in our country. No further money should be spent on it. The idea should be abandoned,” he said.
Lord Steyn questioned whether the government’s competence in running an identity card system had been demonstrated, citing numerous data losses since May 2007 – including the well-publicised loss of two discs of child benefit data lost by HM Revenue & Customs which affected 25 million individuals; the loss of details of 3 million driving test candidates, including names, addresses and telephone numbers; and the theft of a laptop which contained the names, addresses and bank details of 10,000 National Health Service employees. Such instances, he said, “legitimately prompt the question whether the British public should have confidence in the scheme the government proposes to introduce”. He also queried whether “as we head into what may be a prolonged economic downturn, this is an opportune time for the introduction of an ID card scheme.”
Lord Steyn went on to say that successive UK governments had constructed one of the most comprehensive and technologically advanced systems in the world. “The Home Office proudly asserts that comprehensive surveillance has become routine,” he said. “If that is true, the resemblance to the world of Kafka is no longer so very distant.” He referred to the estimated 4.2 million CCTV cameras in operation in the UK. “It is said that a person living and working in London is likely to be filmed about 300 times on an average day,” he said.
Lord Steyn also said that there was “little hope of the Executive taking action to counter the excesses of the surveillance society. On the contrary, the state relentlessly acts to extend surveillance practices and to diminish correspondingly our civil liberties.”
Speaking at the Farrer’s Building second biennial lecture in memory of Lord Williams of Mostyn, Lord Steyn highlighted the lack of evidence that a National Identity Register – which will store geographical information, biometric data and administrative data linked to the use of ID cards – will serve to combat serious crime, and expressed concerns about the privacy implications for members of the public given the series of security leaks which have occurred.
“In my view a national identity card system is not necessary in our country. No further money should be spent on it. The idea should be abandoned,” he said.
Lord Steyn questioned whether the government’s competence in running an identity card system had been demonstrated, citing numerous data losses since May 2007 – including the well-publicised loss of two discs of child benefit data lost by HM Revenue & Customs which affected 25 million individuals; the loss of details of 3 million driving test candidates, including names, addresses and telephone numbers; and the theft of a laptop which contained the names, addresses and bank details of 10,000 National Health Service employees. Such instances, he said, “legitimately prompt the question whether the British public should have confidence in the scheme the government proposes to introduce”. He also queried whether “as we head into what may be a prolonged economic downturn, this is an opportune time for the introduction of an ID card scheme.”
Lord Steyn went on to say that successive UK governments had constructed one of the most comprehensive and technologically advanced systems in the world. “The Home Office proudly asserts that comprehensive surveillance has become routine,” he said. “If that is true, the resemblance to the world of Kafka is no longer so very distant.” He referred to the estimated 4.2 million CCTV cameras in operation in the UK. “It is said that a person living and working in London is likely to be filmed about 300 times on an average day,” he said.
Lord Steyn also said that there was “little hope of the Executive taking action to counter the excesses of the surveillance society. On the contrary, the state relentlessly acts to extend surveillance practices and to diminish correspondingly our civil liberties.”
Lord Steyn, a former Lord of Appeal in Ordinary, has called for the identity card scheme to be abandoned.
The Chair of the Bar reports back
Susie Griffin on the admin that keeps barristers from billable work
Clement Cowley, Partner at The Penny Group, explains how global events can influence the performance of pensions and ISAs, and why taking a long-term approach to investing is often the most effective strategy
Mário Barroso, Head of R&D and Method Development at AlphaBiolabs, discusses what family law professionals need to know about hallucinogens, from the main hallucinogenic drugs encountered in family proceedings, to their effects and the testing options available
Harmony Christian Ministries is the latest charity to benefit from a £500 donation from AlphaBiolabs via the company’s Giving Back initiative
By David Green
At the start of her term, Chair of the Bar 2026 Kirsty Brimelow KC set out a series of priorities for the year ahead. One of those priorities was children in the justice system
As the world becomes more digital, Barbara Vinagre Mota examines international research into the mental health consequences of judges’ exposure to graphic and immersive evidence, highlighting the importance of support systems
In an era of patient-centred care and growing concern over misconduct in medical settings, why do women still lack the right to choose women consultants for examination and treatment? Charles Davey investigates
Reviewed by Daniel Barnett
James McNeill Whistler at Tate Britain until 27 September Rothko in Florence at Palazzo Strozzi until 23 August Reviewed by Stephen Cragg KC
