*/
As someone who visits the county courts several times a week, it is evident that more and more county courts are back to listing in-person hearings – seemingly without rhyme or reason.
There is currently no guidance from either Lord Burnett, Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, or Sir Keith Lindblom, Senior President of Tribunals, to help county courts decide which hearings should always be in person; which should usually be remote (unless there is a good reason for it to be in person); and which can always be remote.
Various divisions of the High Court, including the Commercial Court, have published formal guidance on determining the mode of hearing. Lord Burnett issued national guidance for the Crown Court to ‘promote consistency and predictability of approach’ while recognising the need for flexibility and local conditions. County courts, meanwhile, are left to decide – somewhat arbitrarily – whether to list matters remotely or in person.
At least four issues arise out of this lingering ambiguity in the county courts. First, each county court has a different policy on listing remotely or in person, leading to confusion. Some courts have an (inexplicable) policy that all hearings must take place in person. Others have a more hybrid approach. Sometimes a notice of hearing stating ‘remote’ will suddenly change to ‘in-person’, meaning that counsel instructed may be in the wrong part of the country. Given that we know how well remote hearings can work, the fact that more courts are automatically putting hearings back in-person is frankly astonishing.
Second, many parties/witnesses prefer remote hearings. Court is intimidating to most and being in the comfort of their own home can help some participants give their best evidence and put their best case. A remote hearing can more easily accommodate work and childcare commitments. In addition, witnesses and counsel with disabilities often benefit from remote hearings as there are fewer accessibility issues.
Third, if a hearing is listed in person, counsel sometimes has to travel halfway across the country when it can be done just as well – if not better – over the phone/Cloud Video Platform. This wastes parties’ time and money. Often the train fare is not reimbursed. For example, the other week I made a five-hour round trip to Norwich County Court for a small claim which had one issue and was dealt with in 20 minutes. A colleague recounted a story where she and her opposing counsel were asked to attend in person on the morning of a hearing. They arrived at court and in fact the judge was sitting at home, so they had to use a conference room to speak to the judge on an iPad (no parties attending). This absurd situation is sadly not surprising to anyone practising in the county courts.
Fourth, counsel’s and parties’ carbon footprint should be taken into account. We have a duty to do what we can to minimise emissions and courts putting hearings back in person without proper thought completely ignores this factor.
This is not to say that remote hearings work well for all, particularly not all of the time, and can bring other issues such as social isolation. Rather, this is a plea for guidance to be given to county courts so some ‘defaults’ can be set and we can have a measure of predictability on the mode of hearings. The following would make sense for cases in the county court:
These suggestions help to further accord the overriding objective. Remote hearings save expense. If witnesses are more comfortable at home, they can give their best evidence. Remote hearings as the default for most uncomplicated matters is proportionate to the importance and complexity of these cases.
Everyone would benefit from clear guidance so that county courts can have a regularised and predictable system that gets rid of the issues that plague counsel and parties whenever they attend court. We must use the lessons we have learnt in the pandemic for better, not for worse.
As someone who visits the county courts several times a week, it is evident that more and more county courts are back to listing in-person hearings – seemingly without rhyme or reason.
There is currently no guidance from either Lord Burnett, Lord Chief Justice of England and Wales, or Sir Keith Lindblom, Senior President of Tribunals, to help county courts decide which hearings should always be in person; which should usually be remote (unless there is a good reason for it to be in person); and which can always be remote.
Various divisions of the High Court, including the Commercial Court, have published formal guidance on determining the mode of hearing. Lord Burnett issued national guidance for the Crown Court to ‘promote consistency and predictability of approach’ while recognising the need for flexibility and local conditions. County courts, meanwhile, are left to decide – somewhat arbitrarily – whether to list matters remotely or in person.
At least four issues arise out of this lingering ambiguity in the county courts. First, each county court has a different policy on listing remotely or in person, leading to confusion. Some courts have an (inexplicable) policy that all hearings must take place in person. Others have a more hybrid approach. Sometimes a notice of hearing stating ‘remote’ will suddenly change to ‘in-person’, meaning that counsel instructed may be in the wrong part of the country. Given that we know how well remote hearings can work, the fact that more courts are automatically putting hearings back in-person is frankly astonishing.
Second, many parties/witnesses prefer remote hearings. Court is intimidating to most and being in the comfort of their own home can help some participants give their best evidence and put their best case. A remote hearing can more easily accommodate work and childcare commitments. In addition, witnesses and counsel with disabilities often benefit from remote hearings as there are fewer accessibility issues.
Third, if a hearing is listed in person, counsel sometimes has to travel halfway across the country when it can be done just as well – if not better – over the phone/Cloud Video Platform. This wastes parties’ time and money. Often the train fare is not reimbursed. For example, the other week I made a five-hour round trip to Norwich County Court for a small claim which had one issue and was dealt with in 20 minutes. A colleague recounted a story where she and her opposing counsel were asked to attend in person on the morning of a hearing. They arrived at court and in fact the judge was sitting at home, so they had to use a conference room to speak to the judge on an iPad (no parties attending). This absurd situation is sadly not surprising to anyone practising in the county courts.
Fourth, counsel’s and parties’ carbon footprint should be taken into account. We have a duty to do what we can to minimise emissions and courts putting hearings back in person without proper thought completely ignores this factor.
This is not to say that remote hearings work well for all, particularly not all of the time, and can bring other issues such as social isolation. Rather, this is a plea for guidance to be given to county courts so some ‘defaults’ can be set and we can have a measure of predictability on the mode of hearings. The following would make sense for cases in the county court:
These suggestions help to further accord the overriding objective. Remote hearings save expense. If witnesses are more comfortable at home, they can give their best evidence. Remote hearings as the default for most uncomplicated matters is proportionate to the importance and complexity of these cases.
Everyone would benefit from clear guidance so that county courts can have a regularised and predictable system that gets rid of the issues that plague counsel and parties whenever they attend court. We must use the lessons we have learnt in the pandemic for better, not for worse.
The Chair of the Bar reports back
Conner Wright, Legal Case Manager at AlphaBiolabs, answers the most frequently asked questions about SCRAM Continuous Alcohol Monitoring (SCRAM CAM®) posed by family law professionals
Ryan Prins of Philips SpeechLive explains how barristers can boost drafting efficiency with AI-assisted speech recognition – while keeping full oversight
Finding available counsel shouldn’t be complicated, says Kaan Kartal of Brieflink
By Kem Kemal, CEO, Henry Dannell
By BSK Financial Planning
For barristers, managing anxiety is a professional discipline as much as a personal one, says Annette Henry KC. This article examines the cues, clues and practical techniques for avoiding overwhelm and regaining calm
If you’ve never been to the Bar Conference before, this is the year to start. Amelia Clegg previews the profession’s flagship event
After a two-year investigation, Karim Khan KC was removed as ICC Chief Prosecutor in July. With the United States threatening to dismantle the court ‘brick by brick’, what’s next for the beleaguered ICC? asks Chris Stephen
Kick off your career at the Bar Council’s Pupillage Fair this October – it’s one of the most valuable opportunities for aspiring barristers, says Amelia Clegg
Join us on Saturday 21 November 2026 at Leeds Beckett University and see for yourself why the North continues to be an exceptional place to build a career at the Bar