*/
Chairman of the Bar, Alistair MacDonald QC, has pledged to “continue the excellent work” started by his predecessors Maura McGowan QC and outgoing Chairman, Nicholas Lavender QC, in preventing further cuts to legal aid, in order to defend a “proud and independent profession”.
His inaugural speech on 8 December paid tribute to the “united voice of the profession” in the form of the Criminal Bar Association, Bar Council and Circuit Leaders, and the “determination and courage of the Bar” in resisting “what would have been disastrous changes, had they been implemented”.
“It was the application of reason and persuasion together with an implacable courtesy throughout. But this time, unlike the many previous occasions upon which we have fought similar battles, the persuasive words were backed up by action,” he said.
MacDonald summarised the position on fees: “The Bar has endured successive fee cuts and we have done our bit”; there was “growing recognition that rock bottom has been reached” and negotiations with Government were now proceeding with “cordiality and calm engagement”. “We have cut the Gordian knot [on] VHCCs [and] are proceeding on the basis of individual contracts tailored to the needs of the case,” whilst discussions take place on a replacement of the old system.
Panels drawn from the CBA and the Circuits will be consulted on any proposals on the re-structuring of fees under the Advocates Graduated Fee Scheme. “Never again will we hear the complaint from the Bar that it was not consulted about new fee schemes until it was much too late. The new system brings a representative selection of barristers into the process as active participants in the negotiation process,” MacDonald said.
“The new system should [also] help to persuade those who do not practise in London that the Bar Council is not a metrocentric organisation, out of touch with real life on Circuit... I will have things to say about the relationship between the Bar Council and the Circuits in the course of my year as Chairman,” he added.
MacDonald committed to discussions with the Legal Aid Agency “about a means by which the Bar can be fairly treated in the allocation of work” and added a note of caution on “the rise of the [unregulated] McKenzie friend beyond any function they were supposed to meet”. He expressed concern for the future of London as a global centre of legal excellence in the wake of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO).
“Our pre-eminence has been hard won. It can so easily be lost. I am really concerned that the changes brought about by LASPO both in terms of access to justice and also to restrictions on the ability of the citizen to challenge, by judicial review, the rectitude of Government decision, will have far-reaching consequences on the reputation of the justice system of England and Wales.”
MacDonald, in post from 1 January 2015, practises in Leeds, where he is co-Head of Chambers at New Park Chambers and was a former Leader of the North-Eastern Circuit. Nicholas Lavender QC returns to practice commercial law from Serle Court. Maura McGowan QC was appointed to the High Court Bench in October 2014.
“It was the application of reason and persuasion together with an implacable courtesy throughout. But this time, unlike the many previous occasions upon which we have fought similar battles, the persuasive words were backed up by action,” he said.
MacDonald summarised the position on fees: “The Bar has endured successive fee cuts and we have done our bit”; there was “growing recognition that rock bottom has been reached” and negotiations with Government were now proceeding with “cordiality and calm engagement”. “We have cut the Gordian knot [on] VHCCs [and] are proceeding on the basis of individual contracts tailored to the needs of the case,” whilst discussions take place on a replacement of the old system.
Panels drawn from the CBA and the Circuits will be consulted on any proposals on the re-structuring of fees under the Advocates Graduated Fee Scheme. “Never again will we hear the complaint from the Bar that it was not consulted about new fee schemes until it was much too late. The new system brings a representative selection of barristers into the process as active participants in the negotiation process,” MacDonald said.
“The new system should [also] help to persuade those who do not practise in London that the Bar Council is not a metrocentric organisation, out of touch with real life on Circuit... I will have things to say about the relationship between the Bar Council and the Circuits in the course of my year as Chairman,” he added.
MacDonald committed to discussions with the Legal Aid Agency “about a means by which the Bar can be fairly treated in the allocation of work” and added a note of caution on “the rise of the [unregulated] McKenzie friend beyond any function they were supposed to meet”. He expressed concern for the future of London as a global centre of legal excellence in the wake of the Legal Aid, Sentencing and Punishment of Offenders Act 2012 (LASPO).
“Our pre-eminence has been hard won. It can so easily be lost. I am really concerned that the changes brought about by LASPO both in terms of access to justice and also to restrictions on the ability of the citizen to challenge, by judicial review, the rectitude of Government decision, will have far-reaching consequences on the reputation of the justice system of England and Wales.”
MacDonald, in post from 1 January 2015, practises in Leeds, where he is co-Head of Chambers at New Park Chambers and was a former Leader of the North-Eastern Circuit. Nicholas Lavender QC returns to practice commercial law from Serle Court. Maura McGowan QC was appointed to the High Court Bench in October 2014.
Chairman of the Bar, Alistair MacDonald QC, has pledged to “continue the excellent work” started by his predecessors Maura McGowan QC and outgoing Chairman, Nicholas Lavender QC, in preventing further cuts to legal aid, in order to defend a “proud and independent profession”.
His inaugural speech on 8 December paid tribute to the “united voice of the profession” in the form of the Criminal Bar Association, Bar Council and Circuit Leaders, and the “determination and courage of the Bar” in resisting “what would have been disastrous changes, had they been implemented”.
As we look ahead to Justice Week 2022, the sustainability of the Criminal Bar remains a critical issue for the government to address
Opportunity for female sopranos/contraltos in secondary education, or who have recently finished secondary education but have not yet begun tertiary education. Eligibility includes children of members of the Bar
Fear of the collection and test process is a common factor among clients, especially among vulnerable adults in complex family law cases. Cansford Laboratories shares some tips to help the testing process run as smoothly as possible
Casey Randall explains how complex relationship DNA tests can best be used – and interpreted – by counsel
Casey Randall, Head of DNA at AlphaBiolabs, explores what barristers need to know about DNA testing for immigration, including when a client might wish to submit DNA evidence, and which relationship tests are best for immigration applications
Julian Morgan reminds barristers of the top five areas to consider before 5 April
The case ofR v Brecanihas complicated matters for defence lawyers. Emma Fielding talks to gang culture expert, Dr Simon Harding about County Lines, exploitation and modern slavery
Barristers are particularly at risk of burnout because of the nature of our work and our approach to it but it doesnt have to be this way. Jade Bucklow explores how culture, work and lifestyle changes can rejuvinate our mental health...
Professionally embarrassed? The circumstances in which criminal barristers may return instructions to appear at trial have become clearer following the Court of Appeal judgment inR v Daniels By Abigail Bright
The Schools Consent Project (SCP) is educating tens of thousands of teenagers about the law around consent to challenge and change what is now endemic behaviour. Here, its founder, barrister Kate Parker talks to Chris Henley QC about SCPs work and its association with Jodie Comers West End playPrima Facie, in which she plays a criminal barrister who is sexually assaulted
Following the launch of the Life at the Young Bar report and a nationwide listening exercise, Michael Polak and Michael Harwood outline the Young Barristers Committees raft of initiatives designed to address your issues of concern
